in

The Disney CEO was informed by Lindsay Lohan that she “should have been paid twice” for her twin performance in “Parent Trap.”

At the Parent Trap red carpet premiere, Lindsay Lohan had the perfect joke for the Disney CEO. The 38-year-old actress, who costarred with 42-year-old Mean Girls star.

Lacey Chabert on Watch What Happens Live with Andy Cohen on Wednesday, Nov. 20, recounted a scene from the 1998 event, when she was 12 years old.

At the premiere, the Our Little Secret actor said that Michael Eisner, the CEO of Disney at the time, approached her and said, “Where’s your twin?”

In her response, Lohan, who portrayed Hallie and Annie in the comedy, who were split up at birth, recalled bringing up her Parent Trap pay.

I’ll never forget what I said, but I was so young that I’m not even sure how I came up with it. “Well, you should have paid me twice because I don’t have one,” I replied.

Lohan remembered to host the 56-year-old Cohen. When Lohan responded, Cohen gave him a high five as Chabert was heard saying, “Oh!” in amazement.

Related: Andy Cohen plays Regina George in Lindsay Lohan and Lacey Chabert’s WWHL Comedies as Mean Girls WWHL’s Instagram page is praising Lohan’s answer this week.

“You should’ve paid me double,” one user commented, “is my mantra and I’m not even playing twins.” Lohan was declared “a star from the very beginning” by another individual.

Get the best of PEOPLE’s content, including captivating human interest stories and celebrity news, by subscribing to their free daily newsletter.

“What’s the most popular role you didn’t end up getting that nobody knows you even auditioned for?” Cohen also questioned Lohan on WWHL.

Instagram users are calling her response “iconic.””I mean, I haven’t auditioned since The Parent Trap, which was the first movie I tried out for,”

Lohan retorted. “I mean, I haven’t auditioned since The Parent Trap, which was the first movie I tried out for,” Lohan retorted.

Related: View 15 2024 Images of Lindsay Lohan That Show the Lohanaissance Is Here In addition to Kristin Chenoweth, Ian Harding,

Jon Rudnitsky, Dan Bucatinsky, and Mean Girls co-star Tim Meadows, Lohan most recently starred in Netflix’s Christmas romantic comedy Our Little Secret.

The actress previously shared with PEOPLE how she feels and what these Christmas films represent to audiences.

“I’ve had the good fortune to witness how they become ingrained in family customs,” Lohan said, “and I continue to derive immense satisfaction.

From being a part of something that can inspire people at such a unique time of year.” Netflix will release Our Little Secret on November 27.